ensure your will is legally sound: advice from the court of appeal IN T&T

CONTACT US HERE

Share This:

​The Court of Appeal of Trinidad and Tobago has recently emphasized the importance of careful drafting and execution of wills, particularly when dealing with elderly or infirm clients. This follows a significant ruling on March 20, 2025, concerning the validity of a disputed will, which has brought renewed attention to best practices for attorneys and the importance of seeking professional legal assistance when preparing a will.

The Case: A Lesson in Proper Will Drafting
The case in question involved the estate of Marie Antoinette Nothnagel, whose 2010 will significantly altered the distribution of her assets compared to an earlier will made in 2004. In 2023, Justice Ricky Rahim ruled that the 2010 will was invalid, favouring the earlier version for probate. The primary legal issues were whether Nothnagel had testamentary capacity and whether she fully understood and approved the changes in her new will.

The court found that Nothnagel lacked the required mental capacity at the time of the 2010 will’s execution. Furthermore, the attorney responsible for drafting the will did not engage in thorough discussions with Nothnagel to assess her capacity or confirm that she fully understood the changes being made. The absence of detailed documentation on these interactions weakened the case for the 2010 will’s validity.

Court of Appeal Guidance for Lawyers Drafting Wills
The Court of Appeal has provided key recommendations for legal practitioners when drafting wills, particularly for elderly or vulnerable clients:

• Assessing Testamentary Capacity – Lawyers must take extra precautions to ensure that the testator has the mental capacity to make a will, particularly if there are signs of cognitive decline. Seeking medical opinions when necessary can help validate capacity.
  
  
• Ensuring Understanding and Approval – Legal professionals must confirm that clients fully comprehend the terms of their will and are not being unduly influenced by external parties.
  ​
• Documenting the Process – Keeping detailed records of client interactions, instructions, and any capacity assessments is crucial in case the will's validity is later challenged in court.

Why Persons Should Seek Professional Legal Assistance
​
While it may be tempting to draft a will independently or use online templates, this case highlights the importance of professional legal assistance in will preparation. Without proper legal guidance, a will can be declared invalid, leading to unintended consequences, disputes, and delays in the distribution of assets.

Benefits of Hiring a Legal Professional:

• Ensures Compliance with the Law – Attorneys ensure that wills adhere to the legal requirements of Trinidad and Tobago, reducing the risk of disputes.
• Minimizes the Risk of Challenges – A properly drafted will, supported by professional documentation, is less likely to be contested.
• Provides Clarity and Precision – Legal experts help draft clear and legally enforceable documents that accurately reflect the testator's wishes.
  
  

Conclusion
​The recent ruling by the Court of Appeal serves as a vital reminder of the importance of ensuring that wills are properly drafted and executed. For individuals planning their estates, consulting an experienced attorney can help safeguard their final wishes and prevent legal complications for their beneficiaries.

Important Notice: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Always seek consultation with an attorney for your specific legal concerns, as only a professional familiar with the details of your situation can provide proper guidance. 
​
​This website is managed by AURORA Chambers; a law practice in Trinidad and Tobago.

Click HERE to receive updates straight to your inbox by subscribing to our newsletter.